Here’s a detailed SayPro Evaluation Rubric for Writing tailored for judging creative writing entries like short stories, poems, and essays:
SayPro Evaluation Rubric for Writing
| Criteria | Excellent (5 points) | Good (4 points) | Fair (3 points) | Needs Improvement (2 points) | Poor (1 point) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Creativity & Originality | Shows exceptional creativity and unique ideas; fresh perspective | Creative ideas with some originality | Some creativity but relies on common ideas | Limited creativity; ideas are predictable | Lacks creativity; very clichéd or copied |
| Relevance to Theme | Strong and insightful connection to the prompt/theme | Clear connection to the theme | Moderate relevance to theme | Weak connection to the theme | Off-topic or irrelevant to the theme |
| Writing Quality | Excellent grammar, punctuation, and style; engaging voice | Minor grammar or style issues; mostly clear and engaging | Noticeable errors but understandable | Frequent errors that distract the reader | Poor grammar and style; difficult to read |
| Structure & Organization | Well-organized with clear beginning, middle, and end | Clear structure with logical flow | Basic structure but lacks smooth transitions | Disorganized; difficult to follow | No clear structure; confusing |
| Emotional Impact | Evokes strong emotions; memorable and powerful | Evokes emotions; meaningful impact | Some emotional resonance | Limited emotional connection | No emotional impact |
| Language & Imagery | Vivid, descriptive language and effective imagery | Good use of language and some imagery | Simple language with occasional imagery | Limited use of descriptive language | Plain or inappropriate language; no imagery |
Scoring Instructions:
- Each criterion is scored from 1 to 5 points.
- Total possible score per entry: 30 points.
- Judges should provide brief comments highlighting strengths and areas for improvement.